Field Notes · An evolving learning library from Angier K9

Cases · Case

Thor

Who Thor is

As the trainers describe him

A young bully-type puppy, strong and muscular. The breed is guessed on film, and 'bully' is the word every speaker settles on.
On film

He's just a little staffy or a little pitty puppy.

Watch at 0:13 ↗

thing is he's a bully he's young

Watch at 4:24 ↗

because they have little tiny necks yeah yeah but thor has a big old huge thick muscly neck

Watch at 6:13 ↗
He loves people more than toys, and wanting to greet them is the energy behind every problem in the case.
On film

He cares about the people.

Watch at 20:37 ↗

want to hurt he doesn't want to hurt people or hurt other dogs or anything like that he doesn't

Watch at 9:20 ↗

want to hurt anything um but he wants to play with them so badly he wants to greet them

Watch at 9:23 ↗
Sharp and quick to learn. Several trainers say so, and one frames it in the same breath as calling him a doofus.
On film

he's a doofus but he's actually he's really sharp yeah yeah like teaching him heel was a lot of fun

Watch at 1:38 ↗

it really quickly just like he does everything else

Watch at 1:30 ↗

He's really strong.

Watch at 2:06 ↗
Not correction-sensitive once aroused. The refresher pickup trainer's diagnosis is that the arousal overrides a cue Thor already knows, and this reading drives the highest e-collar levels discussed anywhere in the case.
On film

the second she greets chloe he's like yeah okay so so he he knows but like it's like

Watch at 11:22 ↗

and the excitements all the way up here he's not exactly like the most sensitive dog with the

Watch at 14:22 ↗
Mouthy and play-biting from the puppy lesson to the refresher. Every trainer names it, and two admit they enjoy it.
On film

He loves to chew, he loves to tug.

Watch at 0:38 ↗

And his conditioned punisher works just fine. The reason I did that was because he grabbed my fingers.

Watch at 5:40 ↗

It's hard for me because I like it

Watch at 7:34 ↗
A face that works on handlers. Kelton says he said it on camera in one of the program videos, and he did, twice.
On film

Why did you send me this puppy?

Watch at 32:02 ↗

I told his owners, I'm like, why did you send me this dog?

Watch at 16:20 ↗

his face I actually said it in one of the videos I said that I was like why

Watch at 15:18 ↗

As the family describe him

Wild with visitors and at the door, to the point where the family gated him in the kitchen. This is the presenting problem, stated at the go-home and again at the refresher pickup.
On film

right stop it yeah well that was a big thing like when christian was coming or anybody would come

Watch at 4:04 ↗

actually gate him into the kitchen because it was just out of control so but he would be at the gate

Watch at 6:56 ↗

He gets very excited.

Watch at 9:36 ↗
Eager to work with people from his first weeks, which the owner says made him easy to motivate.
On film

the only way we got him stuff and it's like he like he wants to like work with me like he wants

Watch at 2:04 ↗
A lover and a protector. The family value his alerting and want it switched off, not removed.
On film

it to he can sit and wait for me to get the door but i mean i still like the protection side i still

Watch at 7:37 ↗

Yeah, no, he wants he's a lover but

Watch at 21:58 ↗

And he's a protector

Watch at 22:00 ↗

The program, stage by stage

A twelve-week-old puppy and a tug toy

Uploaded 2026-02-25. About twelve weeks old by the intake's date of birth (source: intake).

The only footage from before Angier K9 took him in. An unnamed trainer teaches a puppy called Thor, 'a bully' who loves to mouth, by threading recall, out, sit and a 'break' release into tug. The trainer explains each step to a listener. When a female in the room ('her', unnamed; the other household dog fits, but this is not stated) is too much of a distraction for a sit, she is removed rather than the puppy corrected. The family later say they had private lessons with Christian before the board-and-train and taught him early with 'a tiny little cookie on the floor and tap and break'. The title's '8-12 week' age is never spoken, though it agrees with the intake.

On film

so I start saying his name and saying come and then every time he comes I tug he starts learning

Watch at 2:01 ↗

get confused it's better to take a step back remove the higher distraction for that command

Watch at 5:55 ↗

I know you guys have already had some private lessons with, was it with Christian?

Watch at 1:13 ↗

Intake, off camera

Form submitted 5/3/2026, preferred pickup 5/4/2026 (source: intake).

A five-month-old, 55-lb intact male pocket bully, living with an older female dog he jumps on and two cats who avoid him. The family ask for off-leash reliability, calm play at home and listening; the named problems are jumping and being out of control with visitors; the pictured future is off-leash hiking and preparation for protection training. He is reported reliable on sit, fairly reliable on place, come, let's go and out, and with no down, heel, middle, release or markers (all source: intake). None of this is on camera.

Day one: the evaluation

Between 4 and 12 May 2026. Uploaded 2026-05-22.

A walk at Beach Bluff Park, chosen as a moderate environment, with the stated purpose of learning about him. The reads, in the trainer's words: very adventurous, pulls, would take off; engages with tug but with a soft grip; toys lose to people. The e-collar is fitted for habituation and tested: nothing at 5, 10 or 20, a response at 35 on the boost button, and 'not shut down, not repressed'. The release command is set as the first priority because everything else depends on it. The trainer closes on 'a good day one solid performance'.

On film

We're just going to be going out for walkies, and I'm just going to be learning about him.

Watch at 0:24 ↗

And then I ended up using the loose button for a 35

Watch at 9:52 ↗

he's not shut down he's not repressed

Watch at 10:34 ↗

So as soon as I have a really solid release command

Watch at 22:48 ↗

did go buddy here's a good day one solid performance smart boy Thor sit and Thor

Watch at 33:03 ↗

Days two to four: foundations outdoorsTurning point

Day two (watch), a morning session after day two (watch), and day three or four (the Walkies outing).

Three sessions in which most of the program's foundations appear. On day two, inside a tug and ball session, comes 'Thor's first down without me touching it', with no e-collar and not many reps. When a neighbouring dog barks, the trainer makes looking at it the reward for coming when called. The next session names a line rotation (a 50-foot line on day two, now about 14 feet, thinner lines to come), releases from place the moment Thor commits, and makes the release the word rather than the handler's stance. Heel starts, and a struggled down gets no duration added. On the walk the pulling is dealt with first and with 'strictly the e-collar': within minutes the trainer calls him cognizant of the end of the leash, and sniffing and running are the pay. By the end of the outing heel entries are praised and the trainer lists down, sit-stay and down-stay duration, place, leash yielding and heel as improving.

On film

down all right so you can see that was thor's first down without me touching it

Watch at 15:12 ↗

We're just gonna use the distraction as the reward.

Watch at 8:41 ↗

we're in the backyard good boy in day two i had a longer like yellow a 50 foot long line on

Watch at 0:00 ↗

the release is the sound that i make with my mouth the okay and not the way that i'm standing

Watch at 17:45 ↗

on it good boy and we're just using strictly the e-collar for the loose leash walking here

Watch at 1:40 ↗

he's starting to be allergic to leash pressure right you punish the pulling you make sure that they don't do it again and then you reward when they're doing good

Watch at 5:22 ↗

so good you can see his down is improving a lot his sit stay and his down stay duration are

Watch at 12:54 ↗

About day five onwards: the cot he avoided, and home contextTurning point

watch ('let's call it day five'), then watch ('faster than last time'). watch belongs somewhere in this stretch.

The place cot is Thor's one early aversion. At the facility he 'sometimes doesn't want to get up there', and a picnic table he likes is used instead. Indoors on day five he is put on the cot and waited out: he stares at the trainer for what the trainer estimates at fifteen to twenty minutes, then settles and sleeps, and half an hour of near-silence follows (a duration place hold, rule 13). He is released into the 'calm liberty window', free to move but obliged to be calm. The next indoor session starts with him avoiding the cot again. The trainer wonders aloud whether something happened at home, takes pressure off the moment he gets on, and notes that negative reinforcement needs caution. Then a place hold over lunch: he settles faster than last time and stays on through a door knock and the trainer walking round, and the one break is fixed with social pressure and a flat-collar tap.

On film

picnic table so sometimes I place him on the picnic table.

Watch at 1:21 ↗

like please say my release word so I can come sit with you on the couch and I want to say it so bad

Watch at 13:03 ↗

that's what i like to see he's just chilling sleeping thor is doing really good

Watch at 28:38 ↗

Good boy, so we're practicing the calm liberty window here.

Watch at 1:00:27 ↗

Negative reinforcement you gotta use with caution.

Watch at 1:53 ↗

and so he stood up, but he stayed on the place cot. So that's good.

Watch at 29:03 ↗

Middle, the creeping down, and the move to avoidanceTurning point

The second week: watch, watch, the dusk session (watch with watch) and watch. Their order among themselves is only partly fixed.

The middle is started, routed in through the front so a leash cannot wrap the handler's leg, and drilled until he 'goes all the way in'. Kelton later says he put it on cue because Thor already stood between people's legs in the kitchen. The down, obtained on day two, develops a new fault: Thor creeps toward the handler as he goes down, which three sessions call submissive (a 'tendency', a 'submissive wiggle', crawling between the legs). A back tie or double line is proposed and never shown. The cot turns around: 'He loves his cot now', and he passes a re-entry test the trainer calls harder than leaving and knocking. At dusk the trainer names the phase change, 'more about avoidance now instead of escape', walks behind a down-stay for the first time, and then proofs it with his favourite ball, explaining that the dog must be allowed a mistake to get a prediction error. An e-collar recall off Jayden, after Thor ignores the first call, is narrated step by step. By watch there is an off-leash heel with an automatic sit, a down that 'has gotten really good', and a release that is perfect early in the session and not working by the end.

On film

him to come through the front back out through the middle Thor middle good because then the

Watch at 10:17 ↗

submissive behavior we don't want that when he's going into the down we want him to this down where

Watch at 17:14 ↗

he was still looking at what he wanted to look at so i tapped the e-collar a couple of times

Watch at 18:37 ↗

he did everything he had to avoid getting on the cot.

Watch at 2:52 ↗

because that's nope down so he likes to do this thing where he does this submissive wiggle he

Watch at 5:52 ↗

Because the entrance is sometimes harder

Watch at 27:23 ↗

It's more about avoidance now instead of escape.

Watch at 4:54 ↗

Because they need to try something and get a prediction error.

Watch at 2:35 ↗

Thor, heel. Heel. It's a very nice off-leash heel here. Very nice. And if I stop, he sits.

Watch at 7:24 ↗

Off leash and out in public

The last days of the first program: watch, then watch on the day of the go-home.

The trainer's inventory: skills 'far beyond what they were when he first came', everything now off leash, the conditioned punisher working, middle being turned into a 'security heel'. Thor now offers place unasked because he is 'addicted' to the release marker, which the trainer calls ideal apart from the anticipation. The down is still a struggle to get into, even though he holds it well once there. At Bass Pro Shops the standard is set for a pet dog: a sit that folds into a down is fine. What is being proofed is that he still listens and yields to the leash, not that he is uninterested. He recalls away from people he badly wants to greet, heels past another dog, holds a down through a phone call, and needs 'a little bit of negative reinforcement, but not too much'.

On film

heel good boy good job so you can see that his skills have advanced far beyond what they were

Watch at 8:08 ↗

but we are getting him to do everything off-leash now.

Watch at 5:33 ↗

So he's still doing that kind of submissive thing.

Watch at 3:40 ↗

work the duration here sit i'm okay he's a pet dog it's functional obedience here if he folds into a down it's fine

Watch at 1:44 ↗

in places like this very few times in his life so this is crazy to him right so we don't expect a

Watch at 15:05 ↗

He's listening to come. He's listening to heal. He's needed a little bit of negative reinforcement,

Watch at 15:30 ↗

The go-home lessonTurning point

The same day as Bass Pro; between about 21 and 30 May 2026. Parts 1 and 2 uploaded 2026-06-06.

Kelton introduces himself and brings Thor home to the owner, who is alone in the house with the other dog. She lays out the problems that brought them here: the door, visitors (Christian included), a relative with luggage, the kitchen gate, going at the other dog in doorways, play-biting, yanking on walks, and a collar at 10 that did nothing when he was hyped. She wants a sit-and-wait at the door, and she likes his protectiveness. Kelton's lesson is that the sit-and-wait and the place cot are band-aids. What she wants is calm liberty, reached by punishing the specific unwanted act with the conditioned punisher 'ah', giving no command afterwards, letting him 'sit in it' and reconciling. Around that he teaches escape versus avoidance levels, duration as a second dial, the welfare case, come versus let's go, flexi walks with release to freedom, and an e-collar tap 'on a pretty high level' for any yank. He argues it is better to err slightly high than low, and tells the story of accidentally tapping Thor on the collar's maximum days earlier. Part 2 closes the visit: a door down-stay without the collar, 'eh eh' and no second cue, and on the second try 'He stayed.'

On film

I'm Kelton.

Watch at 0:31 ↗

But what I'll say is all those are just band-aids.

Watch at 8:41 ↗

you just punish the behavior you don't want but then you don't give any commands after that you don't allow you don't like disallow them now from an area you just say hey in a way they understand don't ever do that again

Watch at 17:09 ↗

but yeah i mean his recall is good enough he can be off leash now but um i recommend using a long

Watch at 46:29 ↗

on you at all yeah tap the e-collar on a pretty high level yeah um that was one other thing that

Watch at 1:07:32 ↗

He stayed.

Watch at 6:14 ↗

Home, off camera

Late May to mid-June 2026. Nothing filmed.

What happened at home is known only from what the family report at the refresher pickup. Place and sit held up, the down did not, and the e-collar was used little or at 50 depending on which answer is taken. With visitors he still jumps at the gate and at people, sometimes sits if told softly, sometimes cannot be stopped and is put outside. He holds a place until a visitor greets the other dog and then breaks. Nobody on film states why the refresher was booked.

On film

He doesn't want it down.

Watch at 2:10 ↗

Sometimes he'll keep jumping though and we just have to get him away from the person.

Watch at 9:55 ↗

But then once she comes in and goes to greet Chloe.

Watch at 11:18 ↗

but he would release himself out of it.

Watch at 28:07 ↗

The refresher pickupTurning point

On or before 23 June 2026.

The trainer (content points to Kelton; see people) checks the skills and finds the down gone when Thor is excited: 'This is why I wish I had an e-collar on him.' The diagnosis is that the arousal overwhelms a cue Thor knows, and that there is little defensive aggression in him. The ideal is restated as no command at the door at all. The plan is to let him choose, mark 'ah', and if he carries on, tap the e-collar at 75 to 90, 'somewhere in the 90s', because the visitor problem is predictable and a few very clear no's weigh less than years of frustration. The trainer says plainly that this is not a teaching level and that he has never needed a 90 to teach a down. He proposes staging a visitor arrival at drop-off with the collar on.

On film

Down. Down. No. Down. This is why I wish I had an e-collar on him.

Watch at 4:04 ↗

where that comes from with like because like thor doesn't have any like there's not a ton of

Watch at 9:05 ↗

setting right where it's very exciting there's another dog a person's coming in is you let him

Watch at 11:55 ↗

75 90 90 something like that um and it's like is that like a teaching level not really that's not

Watch at 14:03 ↗

to almost every dog on the planet,

Watch at 15:10 ↗

The refresher: 'he knows everything', and the lesson that followed

Late June to 20 August 2026 at the latest. One filmed session, two untaped, and the lesson at drop-off.

A different trainer (not Kelton: he calls 'Kelson' mid-lesson) runs the refresher's one filmed session and the drop-off lesson. The session's premise is that Thor knows everything and needs it reinforced. He tests the end of the leash, the implied stay is 'kicked back in', and his working level is put at about 35. The heat cuts the session short. At drop-off the trainer does not demonstrate the staged visitor scenario proposed at pickup. Instead the lesson is about yanking: the flexi is locked short in the house and the black button is pressed, with no word, every time he hits the end, so the leash end and the stimulation become one thing. The collar is refitted after a twist test, and the trainer explains that a loose fit leads owners to crank the level. Then the chain of command, disobedience, marker, e-collar; one cue only; no shouting 'down' at a jumping dog; keep sit and down distinct. The family member says why they keep training: people are scared of him.

On film

Yeah, so really, he knows everything.

Watch at 1:12 ↗

good job so the big thing is just getting him to exercise that implied stay which he's doing good

Watch at 3:16 ↗

all right so we're gonna do here is the big issue is like he's yanking on you because he thinks so

Watch at 0:00 ↗

So I'm gonna give Kelson a call really really quick while you're doing that

Watch at 4:17 ↗

Like a chain of events the e-collar is always the last thing in the event. The disobedient behavior is is in the middle and the command is the first part.

Watch at 15:35 ↗

And I want him to be in control because he is the type of dog he is and people are scared of him.

Watch at 21:32 ↗

Skills

Down

At the startDoesn't know at all (source: intake). Needed physical help on day one and day two.
By the end'His down has gotten really good' by the second week and held through Bass Pro distractions, yet lost at home. At the refresher pickup the family say he 'doesn't want it down', and he fails it repeatedly when excited. The fault that persisted through the whole program is going into it: creeping, wiggling or crawling toward the handler.

How it was taught

Inside play first, with repeated cues and help, until the first unassisted down on day two ('didn't have to touch it... didn't have to use the e-collar'). Duration was withheld after a struggled rep. Then proofing: handler movement, walking behind, a thrown favourite ball, a play stance, all with the release as the only exit. The creeping was named as submissive and a back tie or double line proposed; neither is shown. At the refresher: one cue, marker then e-collar for a break, and the down must be a down.

On film

it didn't have to touch it didn't have to uh use the e-collar didn't have to do anything at all

Watch at 15:26 ↗

boy good boy I'm not gonna try to put any duration on that when he struggled

Watch at 21:02 ↗

you know down come on let me help you down

Watch at 23:42 ↗

he's at um so i might have to do like a little bit of a back tie that's one easy way to do it

Watch at 17:18 ↗

His down has gotten really good.

Watch at 3:30 ↗

He doesn't want it down.

Watch at 2:10 ↗

I, the down always has to be a down.

Watch at 12:05 ↗

Place

At the startUsually reliable in low distraction (source: intake). On film he avoided the facility cot at first.
By the endLoved by mid-program; held through a door knock, the trainer walking round and a re-entry. At home he goes to it but releases himself, and he breaks when a visitor greets the other dog.

How it was taught

A picnic table he liked as a stand-in. Waiting him out on the cot without release until he settled. Release on commitment. Minimal pressure for breaks (social pressure, a flat-collar tap). Distraction added in named steps: sitting on the couch, door knock, walking around, leaving and re-entering.

On film

place good good sometimes he doesn't want to get up there good good boy good

Watch at 5:50 ↗

he has chilled out a little bit now you can see he's settled in the cot you can see his extremely

Watch at 17:26 ↗

him there. That was mostly just social pressure and just kind of like tapped him with the flat

Watch at 28:27 ↗

He did not like the cot at first.

Watch at 2:47 ↗

he doesn't like place very much, Thor, come, place, oh, well, now he got right on it this

Watch at 8:36 ↗

he was getting up and walking away.

Watch at 27:59 ↗

Release ('okay')

At the startDoesn't know at all (source: intake), though a 'break' release was taught before the program. Named the first priority on day one.
By the endSo valued that Thor offers place to earn it. Anticipation persisted, and at the go-home Kelton warns the family that Thor responds to a high-pitched 'okay'.

How it was taught

Paid with contact and play. Released from different body positions so the word, not the stance, is the signal. Proofed against a happy face and a play stance.

On film

It'll be much easier for me to teach him everything else

Watch at 22:55 ↗

i was going to release him so he started anticipating the release so this time i

Watch at 17:32 ↗

Because I've gotten Thor addicted to the release marker, which is okay.

Watch at 4:08 ↗

Okay. Come on. Okay. Thor. Thor. Come on. Okay. Okay. Come on. The release isn't working

Watch at 8:53 ↗

Good boy. Yeah, he's also used to hearing it high-pitched by the way with the release command instead of okay

Watch at 46:02 ↗

Loose-leash walking and leash yielding

At the startPulls hard; would take off (day one).
By the endCognizant of the leash within minutes on day three or four, yielding in Bass Pro on a locked flexi. At home, by the owner's account, still 'yanking me down the street', and yanking is 'the big issue' at the refresher lesson.

How it was taught

E-collar paired with hitting the end of the leash, praise the moment he comes off it, freedom anywhere so long as the leash stays loose, sniffing as the reward. At the refresher it was taught to the family indoors on a short locked flexi, black button every time, no word.

On film

he's very cognizant of the end of the leash now he's very aware and so now we just need a distraction to continue to proof it

Watch at 3:15 ↗

So I'm cool if he sniffs all around and does whatever else, just as long as when I do lock it and I put pressure on it, right, that he doesn't lean in the leash tension. He has to give to it immediately.

Watch at 11:30 ↗

to need to get used to saying it right away yeah and i want to be able to walk him and like you

Watch at 1:07:03 ↗

Yes, you can see he reacts each time he hits the end.

Watch at 1:24 ↗

to do with the leash when he when he hits the end of the leash the idea is that he learns that the

Watch at 1:24 ↗

Recall, and come versus let's go

At the startUsually reliable in low distraction (source: intake); 'responding to the recall really quickly' on day one.
By the endRecalls off people he wants to greet in a store. Kelton calls it good enough for off leash and recommends a long line for the owner's comfort. Come is defined as 'come and wait for further instructions'.

How it was taught

Paid with play and with the distraction itself (go and look at the dog after coming). E-collar taps and more pressure when he stalled three-quarters of the way in. Released to go and look again afterwards. Called over sometimes just for play, so a call does not always mean work.

On film

He gets to go look at the dog if he listens.

Watch at 8:43 ↗

he felt it started coming and then he got about three quarters of the way here and then he kind

Watch at 18:42 ↗

you have to come okay very important we don't get hit by cars and stuff dude

Watch at 18:03 ↗

when you say come he comes to you and waits for further instructions okay that's how they're different than let's go so come and let's go are very very distinct

Watch at 10:32 ↗

Heel, and heel entry

At the startDoesn't know at all (source: intake).
By the endOff-leash heel with an automatic sit; heel past a dog in a store. Kelton says heel was fun to teach because Thor picked it up efficiently, and that off-leash heel is harder than on leash.

How it was taught

Started on a 14-foot line. Entries worked separately. Releases to run so he does not auto-heel. Pace changes, turns and sidesteps. Never a 'perma heel'.

On film

heel. Good. That's a nice heel entry. Good. Get right into the heel. And he stops when I stop.

Watch at 34:37 ↗

Thor sit good boy run run run good job that way I can get him where he's not trying to auto heal for no reason

Watch at 26:21 ↗

Really good focus on me. He's looking up at me. He's following me on the turns.

Watch at 4:31 ↗

Good, so he's proofing that heel under distractions. Heel, it's about duration and distraction. So he's gotta stay focused on the heel even though this is really distracting for him.

Watch at 13:40 ↗

Middle ('security heel')

At the startDoesn't know at all (source: intake), but Thor already stood between the family's legs in the kitchen.
By the endPerformed, but the least practised skill by Kelton's own account. At the refresher pickup he still goes round the back instead of through.

How it was taught

Put on cue because he already did it. Routed through the front so the leash cannot wrap, with 'all the way in' as the criterion. Walk forward to give him room to spin.

On film

middle just for fun for fun for funsies it's not normally included in the program but i just he

Watch at 11:45 ↗

middle. Nope. You got to go all the way in. You got to go all the way in.

Watch at 3:47 ↗

he's learned a middle command and i'm very i'm starting to transform that into a security heel

Watch at 8:43 ↗

between your legs yeah cuz I didn't get to spend as much time on that one as I

Watch at 2:56 ↗

Yeah, I wish I could get him to do it a little bit more consistently going through okay

Watch at 6:41 ↗

Calm liberty at the door and with visitors

At the startOut of control with visitors, gated in the kitchen (source: intake and the owner on film).
By the endNot achieved on film. It is the goal named at the go-home and again at the refresher pickup. A door down-stay (a work-window command, not calm liberty) held on the second try at the go-home.

How it was taught

Practised as the 'calm liberty window' indoors at the facility: free shaping with punishment, where only inappropriate choices are marked. Given to the family as: no command, let him choose, 'ah', back it up. At the pickup, a high collar level for this one predictable scenario and a staged visitor arrival, which is never shown.

On film

to be teaching him in the calm liberty window. Namely, that he has freedom to walk around, to do

Watch at 11:54 ↗

Right. So like the picture that you really would

Watch at 10:50 ↗

was like i don't think so that's not actually ideal ideal would just be you say nothing and

Watch at 10:41 ↗

Conditioned punisher ('ah', 'uh-uh', 'eh eh')

At the startMarker 'nope' doesn't know at all (source: intake).
By the end'works just fine' in the late program. Ranked by Kelton among the top three to five commands for a family dog. The family are still getting used to it at the go-home.

How it was taught

Introduced after Thor grabbed the trainer's fingers. For the family: mark, back it up until he looks punished, no command afterwards, let him sit in it, reconcile. At the refresher it is fixed as the third link in command, disobedience, marker, e-collar.

On film

super uncommon in my experience yeah um so uh the condition punisher word that i used was ah

Watch at 4:24 ↗

because like if I send a dog home uh-huh without a conditioned punisher right but they knew like commands i didn't even come close to doing my job

Watch at 6:07 ↗

How the method adapted

Thor was an easy dog to teach and a hard dog to stop. The adaptations sort accordingly. Early ones are about keeping a strong, mouthy puppy playing while he learned. Later ones are about how much consequence it takes to reach a dog who is 'not exactly the most sensitive' once aroused. The largest adaptation in the case, a collar level of 75 to 90s for one situation, comes at the refresher pickup, and nothing on film shows it being used.

The cot he avoided was replaced, then waited out, then barely pressured.

He did everything he could to avoid the cot, and the trainer wondered on camera whether something at home had put him off. So a picnic table he liked stood in for it. On the cot the trainer outlasted the stare instead of forcing him. When he broke, the fix was social pressure and a flat-collar tap, with the e-collar explicitly not needed, and a spoken caution about negative reinforcement.

On film

down, we've been working on the place cot over there. He likes to get up on the

Watch at 1:18 ↗

collar to show him to get back up on the cot. No e-killer or anything like that is necessary in

Watch at 28:33 ↗

and then it took a few days and then he started going on it he was sleeping on like like chloe

Watch at 21:35 ↗

What he wanted most (people, other dogs, his favourite ball) was turned into the reward and the proof.

Toys lost to people on day one. So a barking neighbour dog, a passing staff member and his own ball became, in turn, the payment for coming and the test of the down.

On film

We're just gonna use the distraction as the reward.

Watch at 8:41 ↗

up. It's because something exciting is happening. Throw his favorite ball. It's the one he likes

Watch at 1:30 ↗

A habit of his own was put on cue.

He already stood between people's legs in the family kitchen. Kelton turned it into the middle 'just for fun', outside the normal program, because 'it's something they already want to do'.

On film

liked going between my legs so i told him to do it yeah in the kitchen he would just come right

Watch at 11:50 ↗

where I was like he did it and I was like oh well I'm gonna teach you that

Watch at 3:06 ↗

The creeping down was named three ways and treated as a submissive escape, not confusion. The tool proposed for it never appears.

The trainers read his wiggle toward the handler as submissive behaviour that becomes a way to get out of things if not corrected early. A back tie or double line was proposed twice.

On film

get him out of that tendency to move towards me and like kind of like pushing do some like that

Watch at 17:10 ↗

wants to wiggle over i'm trying to break him of that habit it's a bad habit that's good

Watch at 6:00 ↗

I am gonna end up back-tying him.

Watch at 3:44 ↗

The standard was set by his life: a pet dog doing functional obedience. The refresher then tightened it.

At Bass Pro a sit that folds into a down is 'fine' because he is a pet dog. At the go-home Kelton corrects a down-for-sit without punishing it, as confusion. At the refresher the rule becomes 'the down always has to be a down', with a pull-up into the sit, because tolerating the fold can leave a dog who no longer sits. These are different trainers at different points in the case, and the change is recorded, not resolved.

On film

work the duration here sit i'm okay he's a pet dog it's functional obedience here if he folds into a down it's fine

Watch at 1:44 ↗

so I just correct it I don't punish it because it's more just a confused thing other they're not like a rebellious thing when he lays down instead of sits

Watch at 54:14 ↗

that's fine, but you can get it to where he won't sit anymore, he'll just down when you say sit.

Watch at 12:09 ↗

Collar levels were set for a tough dog, and in one situation set very high on purpose.

Nothing below 35 registered on day one, the family's 10 did nothing when he was hyped, and the refresher pickup trainer read him as blowing off anything not meaningful once aroused. The recommendation of 75 to 90s is confined to the predictable visitor scenario, justified by total welfare, and explicitly called not a teaching level. The refresher trainers themselves worked him at 30 to 35.

On film

it yeah so we had to raise it when he got super hyped up like really hyped up we were just like

Watch at 1:09:07 ↗

in the 90s and then just because you yeah because even if he yelps or something like that don't

Watch at 14:52 ↗

or 35 excuse me it can be a big difference you sit on about a 35 on the

Watch at 3:45 ↗

For leash pressure the marker was dropped and the leash itself made the signal.

Everything else in the refresher is taught marker-then-collar. For yanking, the family is told to use no word at all, so that the end of the leash and the stimulation become one thing, and to keep the remote out of sight because Thor had learned to watch for it.

On film

okay yeah and so i will say it with the with the leash you don't have to say any word everything

Watch at 1:13 ↗

he started to learn what this was yeah he started to see it in my hand and then he started seeing

Watch at 1:43 ↗

Sessions were cut for heat, in both stays.

A heavily muscled puppy in warm weather. Three sessions stop or rest early because of the heat.

On film

Can't let him get overheated, you know?

Watch at 14:43 ↗

because as it starts getting hotter,

Watch at 19:54 ↗

What the family was told

Punishment that lands: mark it, back it up, no command, reconcile

like okay right you kind of reconcile with them like you just like let them sit in it for a second right and then you go okay and then you like pet them and you let them go do their thing

Watch at 17:25 ↗

you know you punish them properly like they the message was received not if they stopped doing it okay but if they look like they got punished

Watch at 18:30 ↗

right right and i don't even tell him a command because then it switches okay right if i tell

Watch at 31:17 ↗

day so yeah yeah if if he doesn't have this on you you still need to penalize him just do it a

Watch at 3:18 ↗

Escape level versus avoidance level, and why a higher level is justified

But if you want him to avoid it in the future, you have to raise the level of the punishment.

Watch at 35:25 ↗

why do something like that i'm looking at the total outcome okay what's the total outcome

Watch at 37:25 ↗

Right. What's traumatizing is a lack of clarity. If you punish them and they can't make the

Watch at 1:09:52 ↗

between you and then that's like discord right um and so then i'm you know weighing between all

Watch at 13:23 ↗

The four windows: what the family want is calm liberty, not a command at the door

the third one though is calm liberty okay the most common place that that happens is the house

Watch at 9:51 ↗

right? Sprinting around the house, running at people, jumping around the

Watch at 10:42 ↗

make the choice you don't tell him anything yeah you let him go to do it and then you tell him

Watch at 12:00 ↗

Come versus let's go, and a long line for the owner's comfort

right so there's a big difference between these two there is let's go and there's come let's go means he could like come with you and just like walk by you

Watch at 48:38 ↗

line like that just so then it normally for your own comfort so you have something you can grab if

Watch at 46:36 ↗

Walks: flexi, release to freedom, and no pulling ever

using negative reinforcement and you're using release to freedom okay that's all you need you don't need treats or anything else

Watch at 56:14 ↗

leash pressure is never allowed right you're not allowed to pull on the leash

Watch at 58:06 ↗

every time i want you to have like it locked and he's hitting the end of the leash so use the the

Watch at 0:07 ↗

Maintenance: practise, play with commands in it, and rewatch the videos

with dogs we can give you a new engine but you got to learn how to drive it and you got to make sure that you're changing the oil

Watch at 5:43 ↗

a couple times a week spend 10 minutes playing with them and putting commands in the play

Watch at 49:43 ↗

much video footage is because I expect that you can you go back and watch all

Watch at 1:05:18 ↗

The correction chain and one cue

because really the rule is you say it one time

Watch at 10:53 ↗

jumping a lot of people will start yelling like down we're really down as its own command if they're jumping you should punish it

Watch at 14:33 ↗

Don't tell him down again.

Watch at 5:53 ↗

Equipment: collar fit, the remote, nights

but there's a second one okay um basically if you can fit your finger in the collar and twist like

Watch at 7:20 ↗

the first week they're back just keep it in your pocket right first week right yeah

Watch at 13:53 ↗
In the family's own words

At the go-home, the owner's picture of the door, and her liking for his protectiveness.

On film

it to he can sit and wait for me to get the door but i mean i still like the protection side i still

Watch at 7:37 ↗

At the go-home, the other dog in the doorway.

On film

about or to cover anything like that like i said when they were going in and out the door he would

Watch at 1:02:29 ↗

At the go-home, the owner's own discomfort with punishment, and her reason to go ahead anyway.

On film

But I don't want him to keep doing the stuff

Watch at 3:53 ↗

At the refresher lesson, why they keep training, and the wish for occasional mini-trainings.

On film

And I want him to be in control because he is the type of dog he is and people are scared of him.

Watch at 21:32 ↗

because i feel like if he starts to sway yeah just like get back right i mean because like if you were

Watch at 21:04 ↗

Outcomes

What the trainers reported

His skills have advanced far beyond intake, and everything is done off leash.

The first-program trainer, late in the stay (watch)

On film

heel good boy good job so you can see that his skills have advanced far beyond what they were

Watch at 8:08 ↗

but we are getting him to do everything off-leash now.

Watch at 5:33 ↗

He knows all the commands, and his recall is good enough to be off leash. What remains is the family learning to drive.

Kelton, at the go-home

On film

just now he knows all the commands it's more going to be like learning to drive a car like

Watch at 1:04:41 ↗

but yeah i mean his recall is good enough he can be off leash now but um i recommend using a long

Watch at 46:29 ↗

Place and sit held up at home; the down did not.

The family, at the refresher pickup

On film

You've been good with place.

Watch at 2:06 ↗

He doesn't want it down.

Watch at 2:10 ↗

At the refresher he knew everything; it only needed kicking back in.

The refresher trainer

On film

on um he already knew it we just had to kick it back in okay good job thor good job let's go

Watch at 3:25 ↗

Calmer at drop-off than at pickup.

The refresher-lesson trainer

On film

oh or what's up buddy yeah but he's way more chilled out than when i picked him up so i you

Watch at 14:00 ↗

What the footage shows

The first unassisted down, on day two, in play, and the trainer's account that it took few reps.

On film

down all right so you can see that was thor's first down without me touching it

Watch at 15:12 ↗

A puppy who avoided the cot settles on it within about twenty minutes, sleeps, settles faster the next time, and stays on it through a door knock and a re-entry.

On film

that's what i like to see he's just chilling sleeping thor is doing really good

Watch at 28:38 ↗

down faster than last time and so i'm gonna try a few drills here where i'm gonna walk around the

Watch at 8:59 ↗

Oh, look at that cute boy, he stayed.

Watch at 27:04 ↗

In a store on the day of the go-home: a recall away from people, a heel past another dog, and a down held through a phone call.

On film

thor come good and you see he wants to that's really hard for him because he wants to go see those people really badly so him recalling off of that is a really good sign that he's doing well

Watch at 4:40 ↗

it is a spam call you can see he stays in the down just fine i'm gonna leave him there see if he stays he wants to get up really badly

Watch at 12:22 ↗

The owner handles recalls and releases under coaching, and a door down-stay holds on the second try with no collar on.

On film

He stayed.

Watch at 6:14 ↗

About a month after the go-home, the down fails repeatedly for a trainer when Thor is excited.

On film

Down, eh eh, down, ah ah, down, eh, down, eh eh, down.

Watch at 3:29 ↗
How it ended. Thor went home.

The ideas Thor's case runs on