Field Notes · An evolving learning library from Angier K9

Cases · Case

Egg

Who Egg is

As the trainers describe him

Shy by temperament, uneasy about things, and unable to learn when the world is unpredictable. This is the trainer's central reading of him and the reason the long walk is run the way it is.
On film

But there's lots of dogs like Egg. And he has a little bit of a shyer temperament. he feels a little bit uneasy about things

Watch at 40:46 ↗

doing that you can teach dogs very quickly because for a dog like egg when when things are very unpredictable, he shuts down or he reacts.

Watch at 42:06 ↗
A flinch and a startle that the trainer has seen since he first met him, attributed - tentatively - to background and temperament together, and described as improving.
On film

So you see he has a little bit of a startle thing.

Watch at 11:37 ↗

egg has a serious flinch response for some reason um probably has something to do with his background uh and potentially just his like general temperament

Watch at 20:35 ↗
He refuses by growling, and has bitten. This is the trainer's account, given to camera in watch; the bite itself is not on film. The trainer frames the growl as a strategy that has worked for Egg for years.
On film

If he doesn't want to do what you asked him to do, he growls. Right. And he's like, no, I'm going to make you do it. I'm going to make you leave me alone.

Watch at 19:17 ↗

And he's bitten me pretty hard in the hand before doing that.

Watch at 19:30 ↗

But it's worked for him for a long time. He's not a puppy. It's worked for him for a couple of years at least, right?

Watch at 19:49 ↗
Friendly underneath the display. At the evaluation his hackles stay up even while he is being petted, and the trainer's first read is that he is friendly.
On film

he just picks his hair up the whole time yeah i see a pet on him and he still just does that

Watch at 51:12 ↗

Oh he's friendly. His hair was a little up. He's a good little boy.

Watch at 51:29 ↗
Very sensitive to the e-collar; it is run at a 'super low level' for him. No number is given.
On film

that one good boy and he's very sensitive to e-collar so it's on a super low level for him

Watch at 18:31 ↗
A dog who stays close rather than ranging - which the trainer treats as a recall problem, not as bonding - but who, on the long walk, does begin to range out.
On film

go see everything but egg and Rufus they have a little bit more of a tendency to stay close to me

Watch at 23:44 ↗

It's tempting to use this as an opportunity to proof the recall.

Watch at 51:05 ↗
He wants attention and asks for it physically; he marks constantly; he will not go in water.
On film

attention egg see he wants he wants attention from me if I don't give him attention he's like hey pay attention to me and he'll jump up and try to lick my face

Watch at 4:04 ↗

He just likes to mark a lot of things.

Watch at 51:29 ↗

I haven't been able to get him to get in the water yet.

Watch at 14:19 ↗

He opened up. Every handler who speaks about change says the same thing, in different words.

On film

but he seems to be getting better with all of it so good boy he's definitely opened up a ton

Watch at 21:11 ↗

As his carers describe him

Found beside the road in a kennel, and newly taken in at the evaluation. The trainer later repeats the story with a hedge ('if I remember correctly') and a crate instead of a kennel.
On film

Where'd he come from? Side of the road in a kennel.

Watch at 52:11 ↗

i got him him out a little bit ago.

Watch at 51:22 ↗

In case you guys didn't know, Egg, if I remember correctly, was like found on the side of the road in a crate.

Watch at 17:15 ↗
Handling broke down during his first bath: fine until halfway, then he snapped at the person cleaning him. Growling on the first day.
On film

So I gave him, right when I got him, I took him to the bath, washed him down, and he was good until like halfway through.

Watch at 52:18 ↗

The first day, the growling.

Watch at 53:43 ↗

so he snapped at you and you were cleaning them

Watch at 56:49 ↗
Has never played. Walks every day. Does not like treats - though the same carers use a treat at his kennel door.
On film

Has he ever played? He has not played. He goes on a walk every day.

Watch at 53:32 ↗

does he like like treats? He doesn't like treats.

Watch at 57:23 ↗

door hand him a treat if he's not doesn't react yeah he gets a treat just for me opening and closing the door sometimes yeah just like the positive counter conditioning a little bit

Watch at 1:03:44 ↗

The program, stage by stage

Found and taken in, off camera

Before the evaluation. Nothing filmed.

His first bath went well until halfway and then he snapped; he growled on his first day; he had never played; he walked daily; he did not like treats. The carers began opening his kennel door and giving him a treat when he did not react, which they call counter-conditioning and say is working. All of this is reported, not shown.

On film

Where'd he come from? Side of the road in a kennel.

Watch at 52:11 ↗

So I gave him, right when I got him, I took him to the bath, washed him down, and he was good until like halfway through.

Watch at 52:18 ↗

door hand him a treat if he's not doesn't react yeah he gets a treat just for me opening and closing the door sometimes yeah just like the positive counter conditioning a little bit

Watch at 1:03:44 ↗

The evaluation at the carers' property - growling to licking in seventeen minutesTurning point

watch, 51:12-68:07. Queued 2026-03-19.

The trainer finishes Roman's evaluation and meets Egg: hackles up, marking everything, jumpy, grabbing at him, growling. He reads the growl as a response to leash pressure rather than as aggression, and the reaction to pressure as the mark of an untrained dog. He tries sit (refused), learns that Egg does not take treats, and switches to what he says Egg does want - to sniff and see the environment - using light leash pressure toward himself and a release. Egg comes, is released, and shakes off; the trainer explains that dogs cope well with pressure if they are given a way to resolve it. He ends sitting with Egg until Egg is licking him.

On film

Hey, buddy. Hi, so there's the reason he probably growled is there's a little pressure back on the leash for you to come for him

Watch at 52:52 ↗

Oh, you're gonna grab at me

Watch at 53:16 ↗

what I would probably do with him like very like like immediately is I would just take him on a walk out on the flexi and teach him that way that's the quickest way for him to learn because he wants to sniff and see the environment

Watch at 58:05 ↗

So he felt a little pressure and was like, oh we resolved the pressure when he came to me

Watch at 58:49 ↗

That's why he shook like they shook the stress off

Watch at 58:58 ↗

I think we're friends.

Watch at 1:04:32 ↗

Christian, I made a friend, he's the eggster

Watch at 1:07:00 ↗

The unfilmed early sessions: the first meeting, the one down, the bite

Between the evaluation and the woodland walk. At least four or five sessions. Nothing filmed or published.

What happened here is known only from later references. The narrating trainer met Egg and was peed on; worked sit every session until it was known; tried the down once and Egg 'did not enjoy that at all'; and at some point was bitten 'pretty hard in the hand' during a growl-refusal. Whether the bite happened during that one down attempt is not said. The walk's remark that the down is being put aside in favour of 'things that won't give me bit' is consistent with that reading but does not establish it (inference).

On film

the egg lad is really glad at least he doesn't try to pee on me anymore first time i met him he peed on me

Watch at 1:37 ↗

I've tried once to work on his down and he did not, he did not enjoy that at all.

Watch at 7:44 ↗

And he's bitten me pretty hard in the hand before doing that.

Watch at 19:30 ↗

StageTurning point

watch, queued 2026-04-11. The Rufus walk that mentions him is queued 2026-04-09.

The near-hour woodland walk is the richest session in his file. It is run to a stated priority: that he opens up and has a good time, because a happy dog is easier to train. The down is shelved. Sit is enforced with light e-collar pressure only after the trainer has satisfied himself that Egg knows it and is refusing; recall is the one thing the trainer says he will fight for, and he plans an 'avoidance level' for blow-offs; heel is shaped on the flat collar with real releases between reps. Egg startles at a noise, dislikes falling pine cones, is reassured near water, blows one recall when another dog appears, and by the end is rolling and kicking in the grass. The trainer predicts off-leash in six or seven sessions, and chooses not to recall him when he starts ranging out, so as not to teach him to stop exploring.

On film

for egg i care more about him opening up and wanting to like be out here with me and having a good time because then i can more easily train him

Watch at 3:58 ↗

teddy was five days egg's probably going to end up being more like six or seven sessions before he's off leash

Watch at 6:03 ↗

So he did blow up my recall that time.

Watch at 43:21 ↗

look do they look they look happy dude like they look like they're having a pretty good time and they probably are and that's fertile ground for learning

Watch at 51:48 ↗

Downs through refusal, and the argument for itTurning point

watch, queued 2026-04-20.

The other face of the method on the same dog. A lure into the down is tried and fails; Egg growls at the trainer over a piece of salmon and does not get it. Two long down sequences - 'down' repeated with 'uh-uh' and 'no' - end in compliance, followed each time by a big celebration and play. Then, for seven minutes, the trainer explains himself: friendship and predictable rules, personal play, cooperation, and authority, because Egg 'has a tendency to buck authority'; growling has worked for him for years and must stop working; clients ask for dogs like Egg to be put down, and telling him no is the humane alternative; a dog's welfare is judged on the whole of his life, not a single moment of displeasure; and Egg must learn to tolerate handling and pressure or he will not get proper veterinary care as he ages. What the recording shows of Egg is narrower than the argument: he refuses, he complies, he whines, and he goes back to playing.

On film

Down. Down. Uh-uh. Down. Down. Okay! Oh! Eggie!

Watch at 12:41 ↗

what are you doing you growling at me for the food

Watch at 15:11 ↗

down down down you can do it yeah good boy eggy good boy eggy

Watch at 16:07 ↗

And we are also establishing authority, right? So like he has a tendency to buck authority where he's like, I'm not doing it. I don't want to. And that can be really dangerous for him.

Watch at 17:54 ↗

egg needs to be able to go to the vet and do other stuff you know otherwise he's not going to get proper medical care he's going to bite people

Watch at 23:39 ↗

Stage

watch, queued 2026-05-05.

Recall, sit and 'let's go' around the aisles; a leave-it at store gear; and two down sequences in which the trainer repeatedly asks for 'all the way' and 'put your butt down' - he gets one full down and the second set ends without a clear one. Nothing is said about how Egg reacted to strangers beyond the interest people showed in him.

On film

down egg down i know that's loud down down all the way come on all the way butt too you. Put your butt down. Egg down. Come on. All the way. Eh eh. Down. There you go.

Watch at 12:38 ↗

Trying to find play

watch and watch, both queued 2026-05-12.

Two short clips aimed at the one thing the evaluation said Egg had never done. Collected from his kennel (the handler expects him to be 'sketchy' at first and he greets happily), he is taken to the play yard because he seems in the mood, let off leash to walk around, and offered toys. He takes a thrown treat, is offered a small ball, sniffs and licks a toy - which the handler celebrates as a breakthrough - and seeks attention by jumping up to lick. A place rep and a recall follow. The handler reports 'some progress'. A toy is never picked up on the audio.

On film

He's gonna be sketchy. He's gonna be like, who is in there?

Watch at 0:15 ↗

get it get it buddy if he picks that up i will i will die of joy

Watch at 2:32 ↗

face. Sniffing a toy. Oh, God, my heart. He licked it. He licked it, guys.

Watch at 3:02 ↗

good boy all right try it a little bit what do we got about six minutes or so and i'm definitely gonna spend a bunch more time doing this because i think we have some progress

Watch at 6:05 ↗

'Coming back home' - title only

watch, queued 2026-05-25; the untranscribed watch was published the same day.

A 196-second recording with two lines of reassurance: something is moved out of the way and a hesitant dog is told it is not a big deal. The dog is not named. This is where the footage ends; the case has no ending on film.

On film

hey buddy yeah there we go there you go see oh good boy so it's out of the way there you go

Watch at 0:06 ↗

Skills

Recall

At the startNo training at the evaluation; he comes on light leash pressure on a flexi and is released.
By the endReliable on leash in quiet conditions across several sessions; blown once when another dog appeared on the woodland walk and corrected; backed by a low e-collar level. Never shown off leash.

How it was taught

First as pressure and release on a flexi, with the release sending him back to what he wanted to sniff. Later on a leash with a micro e-collar at a very low level, raised to an 'avoidance level' for blow-offs, and treated as the one command that must be instant. Deliberately not used when he started ranging out happily.

On film

So he felt a little pressure and was like, oh we resolved the pressure when he came to me

Watch at 58:49 ↗

his recall is looking pretty good he's recalling right away when i ask him to

Watch at 7:34 ↗

i'm trying to speed up his recall a little bit make a little bit more instantaneous so for one of those if he blows me off in the recall i'm just going to use the e collar on uh an avoidance level

Watch at 31:30 ↗

needs to be beautiful and instant for other stuff if they sit a little slower they're down a little slow because they just like that right it's not a big deal like we're not in this for aesthetics we're in this for functionality

Watch at 33:27 ↗

You always come.

Watch at 0:27 ↗

Sit

At the startRefused at the evaluation, with treats rejected.
By the endKnown, by the trainer's account, but still refused at times; enforced with light collar pressure; once given on a single hand motion. Distance and duration begun.

How it was taught

Worked every session. The woodland walk makes the diagnostic rule explicit: no leash direction because he knows it, so a refusal while he is engaged gets light negative reinforcement, then release and fun.

On film

does he like like treats? He doesn't like treats.

Watch at 57:23 ↗

what they're doing and why and there to me it was very clearly he just was refusing he just didn't want to do it right because he knows it and he was clearly engaged with me

Watch at 9:58 ↗

Wow, he avoided everything that time. I need one little hand motion and then he sat.

Watch at 42:41 ↗

Down

At the startTried once in an unfilmed session; he did not enjoy it at all.
By the endObtained twice under repeated cues in watch; asked for in a store in watch with one full down and one unclear set. Not described as reliable anywhere.

How it was taught

Shelved on the woodland walk because it was not crucial and risked a bite. A lure was tried and failed. Then worked through refusal by repetition with 'uh-uh' and 'no', until he complied, followed by a big celebration and play. No e-collar is mentioned in either down session.

On film

I've tried once to work on his down and he did not, he did not enjoy that at all. Um, uh, so, uh, I'm probably going to wait a little bit in this process cause there's no need for me to like jam him up really hard on the down and make him do it

Watch at 7:44 ↗

Down. Down. Uh-uh. Down. Down. Okay! Oh! Eggie!

Watch at 12:41 ↗

It also teaches them some resilience. And you can see like what he goes to is he goes to he accepts the command finally because he knows what I want him to do.

Watch at 20:11 ↗

all the way egg, all the way, all the way, put your butt down, put your booty down, put

Watch at 13:30 ↗

Heel

At the startLagging and forging on the woodland walk; inattentive in the downs session.
By the end'A nice looking heel' for a stretch; 'a sticky point' acknowledged. The e-collar was to be layered in later; that is never shown.

How it was taught

Position made clear with the flat collar first ('where the box is'), with a real release on 'okay' and a return to baseline between reps.

On film

boy let's go good boy egg heel stop so i stop it's actually a nice looking heel right there

Watch at 34:40 ↗

good in it for a second, and he clearly knows where the position is, so I'm just reinforcing that position with the flat collar

Watch at 35:46 ↗

Sometimes you get a little bit of a sticky point with these things.

Watch at 3:51 ↗

Play

At the startNever played, by the carers' account.
By the endPersonal play with the handler (rolling, kicking, hugs); a thrown treat chased; a toy sniffed and licked. No toy pickup, no tug, no chase-and-catch.

How it was taught

Long walks and personal play first, as a 'gateway' to toy games; an attempt to stir his chase instinct with a found object; then dedicated play-yard sessions trying several toys and celebrating any interest.

On film

Has he ever played? He has not played.

Watch at 53:32 ↗

Oh, we're getting a little bit of play coming here!

Watch at 12:07 ↗

trying to get his chase instincts going a little bit I want him to chase but because that would be helpful to get him to play chase and catch with me

Watch at 30:45 ↗

At least we're getting a little personal play now.

Watch at 1:26 ↗

Tolerating handling and pressure

At the startSnapped during his first bath; reacts to leash pressure; growls when he does not want to do something.
By the endPressure is resolved and shaken off on film; the refusals continue to occur and to be worked through. Whether he will accept veterinary handling is never tested on camera.

How it was taught

Pressure with a clear way out and a release, from the evaluation onward; later, pressure held through refusal. The trainer ties the whole skill to veterinary care.

On film

so he snapped at you and you were cleaning them

Watch at 56:49 ↗

Because they cope with it really well if you give them an opportunity

Watch at 59:00 ↗

Come here, Egg, because he won't let people handle him because he's not used to having anybody put any kind of pressure on him.

Watch at 23:57 ↗

Place, leave it, public manners

At the startNot stated.
By the endA place rep after going the wrong way; 'leave it' and 'out' at store gear; loose-leash 'let's go' around a store.

How it was taught

Cues with 'eh eh' and 'ah ah' markers; a store as the venue.

On film

all right eggy come on up here place come on up here egg come on up here no not that way

Watch at 4:43 ↗

around for a few minutes see what we see what we see see how mr egg does inside the ross

Watch at 1:28 ↗

Tolerating handling and pressure

Update. The Day 1 series adds a first day of handling with no demands: scratches accepted, the handler invites sniffing rather than reaching, states that a growl will not make him leave, tries a piece of equipment on him while he sniffs it, and rises in stages from beside him. Nothing in the series shows pressure being applied.
On film

Does that feel good buddy? Does that feel good?

Watch at 0:01 ↗

growl it won't work the growlies don't work on me

Watch at 0:22 ↗

let me see if this fits you I bet you it's too big way too big

Watch at 0:47 ↗

I won't go all the way up yet.

Watch at 0:51 ↗

Place, leave it, public manners

Update. 'Exit' also appears in two wave-1 Shorts, where its meaning was an open question; here it follows place directly, which reads as a release off place.
On film

Egg, place.

Watch at 0:57 ↗

Exit.

Watch at 1:04 ↗

He mostly just listens right away now, so.

Watch at 1:12 ↗

Down

Update. Still coaxed, and one repetition; it does not make the down reliable, but it is the smoothest down in his file and probably late (undated).
On film

egg down egg down all

Watch at 1:51 ↗

the way down come on okay that's a good boy you did good that was a good down

Watch at 2:05 ↗

Play

Update. The Day 1 handler offers a toy to bite and invites 'Go get it'; whether Egg took it is not said. watch is titled a return from play and opens with the toys being packed; how he played is not said.
On film

Oh is Eggie gonna play? Is Eggie gonna play?

Watch at 1:29 ↗

but I'm gonna pack it up with the toys pack the toys up and

Watch at 0:13 ↗

Place, leave it, public manners

Update. A new venue, Lowe's, filmed as one outing in eight Shorts. Marking is handled by watching him rather than by a cue. The Ross outing itself gets a second, spoken account: many people greeted him and no problem is mentioned.
On film

running up towards that lady and all i did was say egg let's go i didn't have to use the e-collar

Watch at 0:14 ↗

didn't have to use the flat collar the leash or anything like that

Watch at 0:18 ↗

he likes to pee on stuff though i have to i have to watch him

Watch at 0:38 ↗

Lots of people said hello to Egg and looked at Egg and he's a good boy

Watch at 0:15 ↗

Tolerating handling and pressure

Update. Two Shorts add being picked up: set up as a test before a park trip and reported as passed ('with no problems'), and a lift into the truck after the Lowe's outing when he did not load on the cue. A third clip has him encouraged through a jump on arriving back after training (probably out of the vehicle; not stated).
On film

And I want to see how he does letting me put him in the truck. I think he'll let me pick him up,

Watch at 0:54 ↗

Oh, he let me pick him up with no problems.

Watch at 1:42 ↗

I want to load you up. Come on. In the truck. In the truck. In the truck. I'm going to lift

Watch at 0:09 ↗

you got it you can do it good boy egg good jump

Watch at 0:00 ↗

Heel

Update. The Lowe's Short grades it in two parts, entry good and heel in motion weaker, in a store setting.
On film

His heel entry looked nice.

Watch at 0:00 ↗

His heel in motion, less so.

Watch at 0:02 ↗

Down

Update. This matches the woodland walk's shelving of the down and anticipates the downs session's pushing through refusal.
On film

they're pretty resistant to it they don't want to go into the down so i'm taking a little bit

Watch at 0:08 ↗

i'm not pressing the issue yet because it's not that that important quite yet i will have to press the issue at some point

Watch at 0:19 ↗

Recall

On film

Egg, come. Come. Go ahead. Egg, sit. Sit. Good boy, Egg.

Watch at 0:02 ↗

He waited. I didn't have to tell him anything.

Watch at 0:18 ↗uncertain audio

From the Shorts

Short clips posted from Egg's training. They are undated, so they sit beside the program rather than inside it.

A first day: let him sniff first

In a series titled Day 1, Egg is worried by loud noises and the handler tells him he is sorry they are scary, offers a toy he brought, then wonders aloud whether Egg is scared or just worked up, and decides it is the second. He invites Egg to sniff him and praises him each time he does. When Egg yawns and stretches, the handler asks if he is feeling a little better.

Watch the Short at 2:31 ↗

On film

The loud noises scare you? The noises scare you?

Watch at 0:15 ↗

Those are scary noises. I'm sorry.

Watch at 0:23 ↗

Eggman, come here! Look what I brought. You like the toy?

Watch at 0:31 ↗

Are you scared? Or is adrenaline pumping through your body because you've gotten all amped up?

Watch at 2:18 ↗

I think it's the second one.

Watch at 2:23 ↗

Sniffies? You can sniff me.

Watch at 2:31 ↗

Thank you. You can sniff me all you like.

Watch at 0:38 ↗

yawn. All the sniffies. Good boy Eggman. Feeling a little better? And a stretch, stretch, that's

Watch at 1:42 ↗

Growling won't make him leave

Later the same day by the series title, the handler tells Egg he is not a threat and will not go away if Egg growls: the growling will not work on him. Egg licks him and stretches, and the handler thanks him for the licks, lets him sniff a piece of equipment he is trying on him (he thinks it is too big), and offers a toy to bite. He says the two of them are friends.

Watch the Short at 0:13 ↗

On film

i'm not a threat i'm a nice guy we're friends i won't go away if you

Watch at 0:13 ↗

growl it won't work the growlies don't work on me the growlies don't work good boy thank you for

Watch at 0:22 ↗

stretching now let me see if this fits you I bet you it's too big way too big

Watch at 0:47 ↗

look what I got you can bite

Watch at 1:02 ↗

Me and Eggie are friends.

Watch at 1:47 ↗

Standing up slowly beside him

Before taking Egg out on a slip lead to play, the handler, who has been down at Egg's level, tells him he is going to stand up, rises only part of the way at first and praises him as he does. Then it is off to play.

Watch the Short at 0:45 ↗

On film

You know what? I'm just going to take you out on the slip and we're going to play.

Watch at 0:31 ↗

Alright, Eggie, I'm going to stand up.

Watch at 0:45 ↗

I won't go all the way up yet.

Watch at 0:51 ↗

Good job, Eggie.

Watch at 0:52 ↗

Let's go play, Eggie!

Watch at 1:19 ↗

'Much more pliable than he used to be'

After a play session, before heading into Southern Pines to try some stores, the handler does a quick repetition of place (getting on a raised bed on cue), released with 'Exit', and says Egg is much more pliable than he used to be and mostly listens right away now. He is called away from a very large dog, then asked for a down; after some coaxing he goes all the way down, is released with 'okay', and the handler says he figured it out fast.

Watch the Short at 1:09 ↗

On film

The Eggman the egg lad and we are going to head into town. We're going to Southern Pines

Watch at 0:23 ↗

Egg, place.

Watch at 0:57 ↗

Exit.

Watch at 1:04 ↗

He's much more pliable than he used to be.

Watch at 1:09 ↗

He mostly just listens right away now, so.

Watch at 1:12 ↗

Come on, leave that guy alone, he's huge.

Watch at 1:30 ↗

egg down egg down all

Watch at 1:51 ↗

the way down come on okay that's a good boy you did good that was a good down

Watch at 2:05 ↗

he figured out so fast he's so smart

Watch at 2:13 ↗

One word turned him away from a stranger

In Lowe's, Egg was keen to go and say hi to people and started toward a woman. The handler says all it took was 'Egg, let's go', with no e-collar, collar or leash pressure, and Egg came away.

Watch the Short at 0:14 ↗

On film

he was really interested in going up to say hi to people

Watch at 0:00 ↗

running up towards that lady and all i did was say egg let's go i didn't have to use the e-collar

Watch at 0:14 ↗

didn't have to use the flat collar the leash or anything like that

Watch at 0:18 ↗

Lifted into the truck crate without a problem

Before a trip to the park, the handler says he wants to see whether Egg will let himself be picked up and put in the truck crate. He does: 'he let me pick him up with no problems.' After the Lowe's outing, when Egg does not hop into the truck on the word, he is lifted in.

Watch the Short at 1:42 ↗

On film

I think he'll let me pick him up, put him in the crate without any issues.

Watch at 0:54 ↗

Oh, he let me pick him up with no problems.

Watch at 1:42 ↗

In the truck. In the truck. In the truck. I'm going to lift you up like Simba.

Watch at 0:09 ↗

Not pushing the down yet

The trainer explains that the down comes easily to some of the dogs he is working with, but Egg and Angus resist it. So he is going slower on the down while they progress in everything else, and says he is not pressing it yet but will have to at some point.

Watch the Short at 0:08 ↗

On film

for brody super easy for angus and egg

Watch at 0:00 ↗

they're pretty resistant to it they don't want to go into the down so i'm taking a little bit slower on that one for them they're making progress in every other area

Watch at 0:08 ↗

i'm not pressing the issue yet because it's not that that important quite yet i will have to press the issue at some point

Watch at 0:19 ↗

Waits in his kennel until he is released

Leaving his kennel, Egg waits and goes out on his release word; the handler points it out to the camera and praises the release.

Watch the Short at 0:00 ↗

On film

You can see he has his release command. He waits and releases.

Watch at 0:00 ↗

Good boy good release

Watch at 0:23 ↗

Meeting people in stores

The handler takes Egg into Lowe's hoping to meet people and chats with a shopper while Egg stands by; the one thing to watch, the handler says, is that he will mark the merchandise if not kept an eye on. In another clip the handler reports that at Ross Dress for Less lots of people said hello to Egg and he was a good boy.

Watch the Short at 0:09 ↗

On film

hopefully we get to meet some people see how egg does i think he's gonna do really good

Watch at 0:00 ↗

Yeah, just out hanging out with the little egg. His name is Egg.

Watch at 0:09 ↗

he likes to pee on stuff though i have to i have to watch him if i like don't keep my eye on him he'll pee on the on on the merchandise

Watch at 0:38 ↗

Egg Lad has most recently been spotted in Ross Dress for Less.

Watch at 0:09 ↗

Lots of people said hello to Egg and looked at Egg and he's a good boy

Watch at 0:15 ↗

His heel: a good start, less steady on the move

At Lowe's the handler grades Egg's heel in two parts: stepping into position looked nice, walking in position less so. The same outing has him called, sat and praised for looking up at the handler's face.

Watch the Short at 0:00 ↗

On film

His heel entry looked nice.

Watch at 0:00 ↗

His heel in motion, less so.

Watch at 0:02 ↗

Thank you for looking at my face. You won't look my face

Watch at 0:00 ↗

On the trail: come, sit, and time to sniff

A trail walk cut into short parts: Egg is called, sent ahead, asked to sit and praised; he is let sniff and mark a tree, and steered round it the right way. The handler calls him a happy dog.

Watch the Short at 0:02 ↗

On film

Egg, come. Come. Go ahead. Egg, sit. Sit. Good boy, Egg.

Watch at 0:02 ↗

Yep, around the tree this way.

Watch at 0:11 ↗

You can pee on it though.

Watch at 0:12 ↗

Egg's a happy guy. He's a happy, happy dog.

Watch at 0:07 ↗

How the method adapted

The method bends to him in two directions at once: towards patience (walk first, shelve the down, keep him happy, keep the collar low) and towards obligation (refusal gets pressure, growling stops working). Both are the trainer's stated positions, in different sessions, and the order of those sessions is not settled. The adaptations are set out in the order they appear in the footage; the tension between the second and the seventh is left standing.

When treats failed, the reward became the environment. Pressure is released to what he wants - to sniff and explore.

He did not take treats, and the trainer's reading was that what he wanted was to sniff and see the environment. A release to freedom was the currency he would work for, and it made the trainer predictable.

On film

what I would probably do with him like very like like immediately is I would just take him on a walk out on the flexi and teach him that way that's the quickest way for him to learn because he wants to sniff and see the environment

Watch at 58:05 ↗

And so you can train a dog without anything else other than what I was just doing. If you have good timing, you know how to do it. You can train them literally with just negative reinforcement and a release to freedom and they'll warm up to you really quick because they can predict what you're going to do

Watch at 1:01:14 ↗

The down was shelved, and negative reinforcement was taught through commands that would not provoke a bite.

The trainer said happiness and trust mattered more than the down, and that Egg could learn how pressure works from the recall and the sit instead.

On film

I've tried once to work on his down and he did not, he did not enjoy that at all. Um, uh, so, uh, I'm probably going to wait a little bit in this process cause there's no need for me to like jam him up really hard on the down and make him do it it's not the most crucial command in this case it's more crucial that he's happy and that he trusts and that he figures out negative reinforcement from other angles like the recall or the sit or things that won't give me bit

Watch at 7:44 ↗

Walks start with nothing asked. For a dog like Teddy or Brody there might be an obedience check at the start; for Egg, the opening minutes are for him to open up.

Because a dog who is enjoying himself is easier to train, and because the trainer reads Egg's emotional state as the governing variable in how well he learns.

On film

for egg i care more about him opening up and wanting to like be out here with me and having a good time because then i can more easily train him

Watch at 3:58 ↗

else how they're feeling their emotional state dictates how well they're going to be able to learn

Watch at 41:04 ↗

Pressure only after a diagnosis of refusal. Before the collar is used on a failed sit, the trainer checks that Egg knows the command and is engaged, not confused or distracted.

Because pressure on a dog who does not understand teaches nothing; pressure on a dog who is refusing, followed by release and fun, makes him start to avoid it.

On film

it's important that like when a dog doesn't do like a command when they fail a command that you understand why

Watch at 9:12 ↗

that's the perfect time to just use a little bit of negative reinforcement make him do it because then the next reps he'll start avoiding um that entirely and then getting released and going and having lots of fun again

Watch at 10:16 ↗

The e-collar is a micro model on a super low level, and the trainer notes that this is specific to Egg.

Because Egg is very sensitive to it; the trainer adds that this is not true of all his dogs and qualifies it by context.

On film

his little we've got a little tiny e collar on this is the micro educator

Watch at 0:11 ↗

um it's not true of all the dogs that i work with but for him um he does not take that much at least out of this context

Watch at 18:40 ↗

The recall is not used when he ranges out. The trainer lets the explorer explore.

For a dog who tends to stay close, going out further is the behaviour the trainer wants; recalling him every time he did it would teach him to stop.

On film

It's tempting to use this as an opportunity to proof the recall.

Watch at 51:05 ↗

go see everything but egg and Rufus they have a little bit more of a tendency to stay close to me

Watch at 23:44 ↗

Growling is made to stop working. Food he growls for is withheld; a down he refuses is repeated until he gives it, then celebrated.

The trainer's stated reasoning: growling and biting have worked for Egg for years; a dog who bucks authority is at risk of being euthanised; so the refusal has to fail and cooperation has to pay. This is the trainer's rationale, spoken to camera; the recording itself shows refusal, compliance, a whine and a return to play.

On film

You can't have it. You can't do that.

Watch at 15:30 ↗

And so, in a process like this, I'm teaching him, like, hey, dude, that's not an option.

Watch at 19:34 ↗

Right. So we have to backtrack that and make it where he sees that doesn't work. But cooperating with me works and then we're going to have lots of fun together. We're buddies.

Watch at 19:57 ↗

Right. It's very clear. And then he does this little it's actually really cute.

Watch at 20:19 ↗

Play is built from nothing, through the walk and through personal play, before any toy is expected.

The trainer's stated sequence: long walks and personal play establish cooperation and authority, and from there toy games, possession games and chase-and-catch can follow.

On film

again it does work take them on long walks get them to do personal play and very often from there if you weren't able to get them to play with like say a ball or a tug toy or something like that this is a gateway drug right

Watch at 15:56 ↗

possession games you can play chase and catch you can do all those things if you establish cooperation and authority on the walk

Watch at 16:21 ↗

What the family was told

To the carers: how to start with Egg

what I would probably do with him like very like like immediately is I would just take him on a walk out on the flexi and teach him that way

Watch at 58:05 ↗

Yeah, well, you can teach him on the walk.

Watch at 53:37 ↗
In the family's own words

The carers' words are reports, not instructions received. They describe his origin, the bath, the first day's growling, the absence of play, his daily walk, his indifference to treats, and their own kennel-door counter-conditioning, and they say it is working.

On film

Has he ever played? He has not played. He goes on a walk every day.

Watch at 53:32 ↗

closing the door sometimes yeah just like the positive counter conditioning a little bit he's been here he's starting to get better with it

Watch at 1:03:49 ↗

Outcomes

What the trainers reported

He has 'opened up a ton' since the trainer began working with him, and they are 'best buddies'.

The narrating trainer, woodland walk (watch).

On film

but he seems to be getting better with all of it so good boy he's definitely opened up a ton since i started working with him um and we're buds now we're best buddies

Watch at 21:11 ↗

He knows sit completely; his recall is good.

The narrating trainer, woodland walk.

On film

worked together, he knows it 100%, he just didn't want to do it

Watch at 9:05 ↗

He is 'learning really well' under the approach in the downs session.

The narrating trainer, watch.

On film

doing with egg and he's learning really well.

Watch at 19:02 ↗

Off leash in about six or seven sessions. A prediction, not an outcome.

The narrating trainer, woodland walk.

On film

teddy was five days egg's probably going to end up being more like six or seven sessions before he's off leash

Watch at 6:03 ↗

Some progress on play.

The handler, watch.

On film

i'm definitely gonna spend a bunch more time doing this because i think we have some progress

Watch at 6:05 ↗

What the footage shows

Within one visit, a dog who growled, grabbed and raised his hackles at a stranger came on light pressure, shook off, and ended lying with the trainer and licking him.

On film

Oh, you're gonna grab at me

Watch at 53:16 ↗

good job egg are you licking me thank you thank you thank you egg thank you

Watch at 1:05:07 ↗

The recall works on leash in every later session where it is asked for, with one blow-off at a passing dog on the woodland walk that is corrected on the next cue.

On film

So he did blow up my recall that time.

Watch at 43:21 ↗

Egg, come. Oh, you thought about it. Eh eh. Come. Come.

Watch at 43:26 ↗

The growl is on film, over food, and it does not get him the food. The down is on film, twice, after long refusals.

On film

what are you doing you growling at me for the food

Watch at 15:11 ↗

down down down you can do it yeah good boy eggy good boy eggy

Watch at 16:07 ↗

Personal play on the walk, and a toy licked in the play yard. That is the whole of the play record.

On film

You're getting hyper, huh?

Watch at 49:35 ↗

Sniffing a toy. Oh, God, my heart. He licked it. He licked it, guys.

Watch at 3:02 ↗

The ideas Egg's case runs on